Stars and Rankings: The Gift and The Curse for College Football Recruits

ByEd O'Brien

4 min read

Stars and Rankings: The Gift and The Curse for College Football Recruits

"Stars and rankings don't matter." I can't tell you how many times I've heard or posted on social media (see Twitter) for over a decade. Of course, the opposite of that is "stars and rankings do matter."

The truth of the matter is that both sides have a legitimate case for its belief. Stars and rankings matter, until they don't matter?

This is not another article that talks about players who had stars and either did or did not live up to expectations. It's also not an article about the fact that the teams that usually win the National Championship often have the best of the best on their rosters.

No, this isn't one of those pieces. This is about the good and bad about stars and rankings. Let's start with the good.

THE GIFT

Let's face it. Most high school football players want to be acknowledged for their talent and want to know how they stack against others at their position. So, of course, they want to be ranked.

There's a ton of websites out there that do rankings on high school football players. However, there's rules to the game. Kids want to be ranked by 247Sports, Rivals, and even ESPN. Rankings by other sites are cool.

However, make no mistake about it, being ranked on one of the "Big 3" can give an athlete more recognition when it comes to recruiting and helps an athlete stand out among the crowd.

Think about it like this: there’s thousands of football players in any state and only 50 to maybe 250 or 300 prospects get stars and a ranking. If you’re one of those players that have any kind of ranking, you stand out. Does it help you get recruited? Depends on who you ask. There’s no question that a kid mentioned as a 3-star, 4-star, 5-star….heck, even a 2-star recruit gets people’s attention.

That’s even more evident when it comes to certain national camps. Whether it’s a Rivals Camp. Underclassmen Camp, All American Combine (formerly U.S. Army All-American Camp), The Opening, or The Elite 11, the prospects talked about the most by the recruiting websites are usually the ones with the rankings.

Why?

It’s because recruiting websites cover college team and recruiting news. 247Sports and Rivals have numerous college-based websites with fan bases who pay to get all the recruiting scoop and team news they can get on their favorite school. That is why you’ll see most articles by the “Big 3” are on athletes that have FBS (Football Bowl Subdivision a.k.a. Division I-A) offers and are ranked.

Yes, sometimes you’ll see the same athletes written about repeatedly and it may get to be tiresome. However, the law of supply and demand is the reason why that happens. I’ll save the reasoning behind that for another articles.

THE CURSE

There are some negatives to having stars and being ranked. I don’t think the negatives at the high school level are too bad. Yes, athletes with stars and rankings tend to have more of a target on their back during real games, camps, 7v7’s, etc.

The bad side of being ranked and having stars is that there are a lot of athletes that don’t live up to the expectations that come with being a 3-star, 4-star, or 5-star football prospect. Then, once these athletes get into college, “stars and rankings don’t matter.” That’s a very true statement.

However, those athletes still are expected to live up to those rankings “that don’t matter.” So, while the actual stars and rankings themselves are null and void, the expectations that come with a prospect into college are still there one way or another.

While it may not be the college coaches that have those expectations based on recruiting rankings, the school’s fan base certainly has them. Without putting anybody under the bus, there are so many examples of athletes who were 4-star and 5-star athletes that were outperformed by 3-star, 2-star, and even no-star athletes.

Some athletes are erroneously ranked too high in high school. There are several athletes that were either ranked as 5-star football players or ranked in the Top 10 at their position by the Big 3 recruiting websites and never live up to those expectations.

Is it the athlete’s fault? No. They didn’t give themselves the ranking while in high school. Unfortunately, they are held to that standard and if they don’t live up to lofty expectation, they’re considered to be a disappointment.

Is it fair to the athlete? Probably not. The pressure over having to live up to what may end up being unrealistic expectations can be too much for some college football players at the FBS level. You’ll continue to see athletes either outplay their rankings, live up to their rankings, or underperform based on their rankings coming out of high school.

Are you an Athlete?

Create a free profile to access the largest network specifically designed to connect athletes to opportunities. Get started.

RELATED ARTICLES
Benefits of a High-School All-American Game

Benefits of a High-School All-American Game

There are over 1 million High School football players competing for greatness each year. All-Star...

ByMathias Torp | Wed Nov 08 2023
5 College Factors to Consider and Compare

5 College Factors to Consider and Compare

Choosing a college to attend is one of the most important decisions a student can make. Researching...

ByMathias Torp | Wed Nov 08 2023
The Different Levels of Collegiate Football

The Different Levels of Collegiate Football

The NCAA created three divisions in 1973, to provide fair opportunities for students to compete in...

ByMathias Torp | Wed Nov 08 2023
The Differences Between College and Junior College

The Differences Between College and Junior College

American football is a beloved sport in the United States, and many aspiring athletes dream of...

ByMathias Torp | Wed Nov 08 2023
About Boarding Schools in the US

About Boarding Schools in the US

Attending a Boarding School in the United States provides the ultimate educational experience for...

ByMathias Torp | Wed Nov 08 2023
Top Volleyball Drills for Beginners

Top Volleyball Drills for Beginners

Are you new to the sport of volleyball and looking for essential drills to improve your skills? In...

ByTiffany Allen | Wed Jul 12 2023
College Sports: Five Tips To Make The Most Of Your Freshman Season

College Sports: Five Tips To Make The Most Of Your Freshman Season

Entering a new situation and thriving is extremely difficult, but being a freshman student-athlete...

ByRebekah Morris | Thu Apr 27 2023
How To Play Professional Sports Outside Of The United States

How To Play Professional Sports Outside Of The United States

Are you a young athlete aspiring to travel the world? Have you wondered which sport(s) would give...

ByNisshanth Perumalsamy | Fri Apr 07 2023
Five Reasons Why College Basketball Coaches Rescind Scholarship Offers

Five Reasons Why College Basketball Coaches Rescind Scholarship Offers

It’s what you have dreamed of, worked for, and waited on your whole life - a coveted college...

ByScotty Jenkins | Mon Feb 13 2023
American Football: How To Play Professional Football In Another Country?

American Football: How To Play Professional Football In Another Country?

Yes, it is definitely possible to play American football overseas. However, this is not common...

ByScotty Jenkins | Thu Jan 26 2023
New XFL Draft Picks use GMTM to be seen by coaches and fans

New XFL Draft Picks use GMTM to be seen by coaches and fans

In just under a month, the XFL will be taking yet another crack at creating a competing...

ByScotty Jenkins | Fri Jan 20 2023
How similar is the NCAA Transfer Portal to free agency in professional sports?

How similar is the NCAA Transfer Portal to free agency in professional sports?

The NCAA Transfer Portal is a great platform that is beneficial to student-athletes. It allows...

ByScotty Jenkins | Fri Dec 02 2022
What It's Like To Play Professional Volleyball In A Different Country

What It's Like To Play Professional Volleyball In A Different Country

At some point throughout their lifetime, every athlete has the dream to play professionally, even...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Nov 16 2022
Four Of The Most Important Skills Every Soccer Goalkeeper Has To Develop

Four Of The Most Important Skills Every Soccer Goalkeeper Has To Develop

Goalkeepers are really the only ones on the field who you can't compete without. Don't have a...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Nov 16 2022
Bucket List: Five More College Football Traditions You Need To See

Bucket List: Five More College Football Traditions You Need To See

Part two of some of the best division 1 college football game day traditions throughout the United...

ByScotty Jenkins | Sat Nov 05 2022
Eight Football Athletes Using GMTM To Find Opportunities To Play

Eight Football Athletes Using GMTM To Find Opportunities To Play

There doesn't seem to be a clear start and finish to the football season anymore. In today’s day...

ByScotty Jenkins | Fri Oct 28 2022
Transfer Portal: Does Every Athlete Who Transfers Find A New College To Play For?

Transfer Portal: Does Every Athlete Who Transfers Find A New College To Play For?

On the 15th of October, 2018 the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) introduced a...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Oct 19 2022
The Four Best Quarterbacks Turned Wide Receivers in NFL History

The Four Best Quarterbacks Turned Wide Receivers in NFL History

Playing quarterback may be the toughest job in professional sports, with just thirty-two jobs in...

ByBryan Armetta | Sun Oct 16 2022
Think you can play college football? Here’s what to expect in the recruiting process

Think you can play college football? Here’s what to expect in the recruiting process

Playing college football is a dream for many high schoolers but the recruiting process can be...

ByScotty Jenkins | Thu Oct 06 2022
How To Participate In The U.S. Aerials Ski Team Digital Combine On GMTM

How To Participate In The U.S. Aerials Ski Team Digital Combine On GMTM

If you’ve ever tried the sport of skiing, you’ve certainly felt the rush that comes when you speed...

ByScotty Jenkins | Thu Sep 29 2022
College Football's "Dead Money": Why Fired Coaches Keep Getting Paid

College Football's "Dead Money": Why Fired Coaches Keep Getting Paid

We’re at the point in the college football calendar where teams are assessing whether they’d like...

ByAndrew Pistone | Wed Sep 28 2022
The Future Of Sportscasting Is In College Classrooms

The Future Of Sportscasting Is In College Classrooms

Whenever fans watch college sports, it’s obvious that their entire focus is on the athletes on the...

ByAndrew Pistone | Mon Sep 26 2022
USA Bobsled and Skeleton Hosts Third Annual Digital Combine For Hopeful Olympic Athletes

USA Bobsled and Skeleton Hosts Third Annual Digital Combine For Hopeful Olympic Athletes

Coaches from the United States’ Olympic teams are serious about helping athletes from different...

ByScotty Jenkins | Thu Sep 22 2022
Running: Can a long distance runner turn into a sprinter?

Running: Can a long distance runner turn into a sprinter?

Long-distance running is very different from sprint. It is interesting to see how athletes...

ByJamison White | Tue Sep 20 2022
What Does Redshirt Mean? And The Reasons Why Players Do It?

What Does Redshirt Mean? And The Reasons Why Players Do It?

Any athlete with a love for competition hates sitting on the sideline, but once he or she gets to...

ByCorey Roepken | Mon Sep 19 2022
Is playing College Soccer the best route to making the MLS?

Is playing College Soccer the best route to making the MLS?

Earlier this month, we witnessed the 2021 Major League...

ByJohnathan Wright | Sat Sep 17 2022
College Basketball: What Is The NCAA Transfer Portal And How Does It Work

College Basketball: What Is The NCAA Transfer Portal And How Does It Work

With the ever-changing NCAA and college athletics scene, transfer athletes have become more and...

ByScotty Jenkins | Thu Sep 15 2022
Trending Up: High School Football Athletes on GMTM - Week 2

Trending Up: High School Football Athletes on GMTM - Week 2

Football is back and tens of thousands of high school football players are on the field making...

ByScotty Jenkins | Thu Sep 15 2022
U.S. Ski & Snowboard Partners With GMTM For Future Athlete Identification

U.S. Ski & Snowboard Partners With GMTM For Future Athlete Identification

Have you watched the Olympic Winter Games and thought, ‘I want to do that’? Now you have the...

ByTiffany Allen | Mon Sep 12 2022
Top Five Skills Every Defensive Back Prospect Needs to Develop

Top Five Skills Every Defensive Back Prospect Needs to Develop

Quarterbacks and offensive player command a lot of attention on recruiting websites, and rightfully...

ByJordan Rinard | Tue Sep 06 2022
How High School Recruits Can Use Twitter To Engage With College Coaches

How High School Recruits Can Use Twitter To Engage With College Coaches

National Signing Day is right around the corner (February 3, for the uninitiated), and now is good...

ByJordan Rinard | Mon Sep 05 2022
How Athletes From Different Backgrounds Are Discovering Handball On GMTM

How Athletes From Different Backgrounds Are Discovering Handball On GMTM

Cinch Smith took a familiar route to find a place in college baseball. The 6’1” right-handed...

ByScotty Jenkins | Thu Sep 01 2022
How To Participate In USA Team Handball’s Collegiate Athlete Network

How To Participate In USA Team Handball’s Collegiate Athlete Network

The handballers that represent the United States in international competition come from a variety...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Aug 24 2022
How Does Recruiting Work in Today's CFB Landscape?

How Does Recruiting Work in Today's CFB Landscape?

Recruiting is an art that takes college football's elite programs years to truly perfect. Building...

ByBryan Armetta | Mon Aug 22 2022
Five Mediocre College Quarterbacks Who Had Great NFL Careers

Five Mediocre College Quarterbacks Who Had Great NFL Careers

We hear all the time about busts, especially at the quarterback position. These are the guys that...

ByBryan Armetta | Sun Aug 21 2022
Does Having a Top Recruiting Class Promise Success?

Does Having a Top Recruiting Class Promise Success?

Although the success of a football program is built on wins and losses, recruiting has never played...

ByBryan Armetta | Sat Aug 20 2022
With Oklahoma and Texas to SEC, what happens to the Big 12?

With Oklahoma and Texas to SEC, what happens to the Big 12?

Conference realignments are a part of college sports. As different schools gain and lose...

ByAria Modirmassihai | Sat Aug 20 2022
Track & Field: Will there ever be another Usain Bolt?

Track & Field: Will there ever be another Usain Bolt?

The world of athletics will never forget the man who rose to dominate the sport for several...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Aug 17 2022
Advancing GMTM’s Mission at the William V. Campbell Summit

Advancing GMTM’s Mission at the William V. Campbell Summit

Today, August 4, 2022, marks the beginning of the weekend to celebrate the 4th Annual Campbell...

ByTiffany Allen | Thu Aug 04 2022
A GMTM Athlete’s Path to Success: Jordan McCray

A GMTM Athlete’s Path to Success: Jordan McCray

It’s a little unusual for a successful football player to only start playing the sport once they...

ByTiffany Allen | Thu Jul 28 2022
5 Mental Tricks To Help a Volleyball Player Who Is Struggling

5 Mental Tricks To Help a Volleyball Player Who Is Struggling

No matter who you are, no matter what kind of athlete you are, no matter how talented you are,...

ByRebekah Morris | Thu Jul 28 2022
Differences Between the NAIA to the NCAA

Differences Between the NAIA to the NCAA

Everyone is familiar with the NCAA and its 3 subsequent divisions as where the top collegiate...

ByAria Modirmassihai | Wed Jul 27 2022
Four Keys To Staying Healthy On And Off The Field

Four Keys To Staying Healthy On And Off The Field

This weekend's tragic death of a Virginia Union University football player has brought up the often...

ByMatt Wright | Tue Jul 26 2022
5 Best Volleyball Drills and Workouts to Improve Blocking

5 Best Volleyball Drills and Workouts to Improve Blocking

In volleyball, blocking is the first form of defense. Your blockers, where you place them, and...

ByRebekah Morris | Tue Jul 19 2022
How To Do A Volleyball Jump Serve: Step-By-Step Instructions

How To Do A Volleyball Jump Serve: Step-By-Step Instructions

The Jump Serve, also called the spike serve, is an essential skill for any player to learn. Players...

ByRebekah Morris | Sun Jul 17 2022
How does the sport of Rowing work in the Summer Olympics?

How does the sport of Rowing work in the Summer Olympics?

One of the oldest Olympics sports is Rowing. It is a sport that tests the level of endurance and...

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Jul 13 2022
What is the Difference between Field Hockey and Ice Hockey?

What is the Difference between Field Hockey and Ice Hockey?

Field Hockey is a sport where each team carries a hard plastic ball with the stick to the rival’s...

ByScotty Jenkins | Tue Jul 12 2022
Two Jobs Every College Gymnast Can Get After Their Gymnastics Career

Two Jobs Every College Gymnast Can Get After Their Gymnastics Career

It is important to understand that you cannot do gymnastics forever. Really, there is not much in...

ByTiana Schoney | Thu Jul 07 2022
The Benefits of Playing at a Power 5 School

The Benefits of Playing at a Power 5 School

Whether you are hoping to go pro or just looking to continue your sports career through college,...

ByBryan Armetta | Wed Jun 29 2022
Five Sports That Could Produce The Best U.S. Rowing Athletes

Five Sports That Could Produce The Best U.S. Rowing Athletes

Cross-country athletes have said for centuries that their sport is every other sports' punishment....

ByScotty Jenkins | Wed Jun 22 2022